E&O Report | Recent Wins For NY Insurance brokers & Agents

E&O Report |  November 2026  |  Volume 41, Number 11

For many decades we have been your E&O counsel. Whether it was when we were Lustig & Brown, LLP, or Keidel, Wheldon & Cunnigham, LLP or now in our incarnation as the Insurance Broker / Agent E&O Unit at Kaufman & Dolowich, I and my partners Stephen Cunnigham and Robert Grande have devoted our careers trying to create and preserve the best, most favorable and fair law in the United States when it comes to the duties and responsibilities an Agent owes to its carrier and a Broker to its Client. And the concomitant duties and responsibilities the Client has for their own insurance.

As I have said time and time again, many decisions by too many judges are wrong and with each new wrong legal pronouncement, it gets harder and harder to undo the ever increasing Bad Law. It is also why we are so adamant about Best E&O Practices as it prevents bad facts as “bad facts make bad law”.

That is why I am so happy to report that in several cases of mine, we got dismissals for the clients at all levels of the NY Court system. One of the reasons is that the E&O insurers for BIG I members via IAAC, care as much about the law as about you, their insured, and have given us carte blanche to do what we have to do to protect the law even if the value of the case might suggest an early settlement. A bad decision from a Small Claims Court is still a bad decision and we will not let that happen.

Decision 1 -Small Claims Nassau County:

A broker procured an HO policy for a house upstate owned by a person in Nassau County. After a frozen pipe burst, the Insured was paid for the ACV with the application of the Co-Insurance Clause in the amount of about $30K. Despite that amount the insured sued my client in Small Claims Court in Nassau County for $5K, the jurisdictional limit claiming a failure to advise!

Despite the small monetary amount I handled the case myself given the critical legal issue of the application of the Duty to Read and the bar to the claim by a signed application. I moved, Pre-Answer to Dismiss and the court granted the motion saying:

“Here, the Plaintiff executed the insurance application expressly seeking $373,000 in Dwelling coverage based on ACV; thereafter obtained both the initial policy and a renewal policy reflecting those same coverage limits and including an 80% coinsurance clause based on ACV; and accepted and retained both policies without objection or reservation until after the subject loss occurred.

Based on the clear and unambiguous language of the signed application, executed by both the Plaintiff and the Defendant broker, the Court finds the application dispositive of the Plaintiffs claim against the Defendant broker. (See Sung v. Hong, 254 AD2d 271, 272 [2d Dept. 1998]; Murphy v. Kuhn, 90 NY2d 266, 267 [1997]). The Plaintiff is “conclusively presumed to have read and assented to the terms of the … policy.” (Motor Parkway Enterprises, Inc. v. Loyd Keith Friedlander Partners, Ltd, 89 AD3d 1069, 1070 [2d Dept. 2011]; see Soshnick v GEICO Gen. Ins. Co., 213 AD3d 965, 966 [2d Dept 2023]). Like in Sung, here, the court finds that the insurance application executed by Plaintiff, naming Plaintiff as the insured and Defendant as broker, together with the corresponding Policies issued in accordance with that application, is dispositive of Plaintiff’s claim. (See Sung v. Hong, 254 AD2d 271, 272 [2d Dept. 1998]). Thus, Defendant’s application to dismiss the Complaint pursuant to CPLR §3211(a)(1) is hereby GRANTED. “

  

Decision 2 – Yonkers City Court:

The insured sued my client in Yonkers City Court, (jurisdictional limit $15K), for “full auto coverage” which he defined as including “Collision” which he did not have at the time of the auto accident.

Using the decision in my Nassau County Small Claims court and the law we cited to get that win, we again moved, Pre-Answer to Dismiss since the Insured REJECTED “collision coverage” when it was offered and signed the application to that effect!

In granting dismissal the court said:              

“Here, plaintiff does not deny completing or signing the insurance application, nor does plaintiff challenge the authenticity or content of the documents submitted by defendant. The application plainly specifies liability coverage only, and no portion of the record indicates that collision or comprehensive coverage was applied for or intended. The clear and unambiguous language of the executed application, coupled with the consistent information on the Declarations Page, “utterly refutes” plaintiff’s allegation that defendant failed to procure the requested coverage. Rather, the record establishes that defendant procured precisely the coverage reflected in the application and accepted by plaintiff.

As in Sung v. Hong, this documentary evidence conclusively resolves the claim as a matter of law (see 678 NYS2d 116 [2d Dept 1998]; see also Vella v. Ability Serv. Agency, Inc., 2025 NYLJ LEXIS 2686 [Sup Ct, Nassau County 2025]). Because the documents satisfy the heightened standard required under CPLR 3211(a)(1), defendant’s motion to dismiss pursuant to that subsection is GRANTED. Having reached this determination, the Court need not address defendant’s remaining arguments under CPLR 3211(a) (7).”

Decision 3 – Supreme Court Suffolk County Court:

A long time insured of the Broker, (auto and HO), died. The daughter was the heir and Administratrix. The HO premium was being automatically withdrawn from the mom’s bank account. While the daughter had the presence of mind to call the broker to cancel the auto policy she did not mention the HO policy. Worse, she closed the bank account resulting in cancellation of the HO policy.

Of course there was a fire and she sued the broker claiming the usual: Special Relationship, Duty to Advise and Fiduciary Duty among other claims. Critically, she claimed the Broker had a SECONDARY DUTY to provide notice of the statutory cancellation.

I moved, Pre-Answer, to Dismiss based on (i) “privity” (no duty was owed to the Daughter), that (ii) the duty, if any, owed to the mother ended at death, and that (iii) NY does not recognize a Secondary Duty to provide notice of cancellation…which here was the statutory under NYIL §3425.

The court agreed on all counts dismissing the case on 11/4/26 saying:

“Here, any potential duty owed to the Mother, ended with her death which occurred on August 25,2023. * * *  New York does not recognize a duty on an insurance broker to provide secondary notice of cancellation of a policy in effect in addition to the statutory notice of NYIL §§3425 and 3426. As there is no duty to provide a secondary notice of cancellation, and since the daughter was not a customer of Bay Harbour, she has no standing nor privity to sue. (see Murphy v. Kuhn, supra; Hoffend & Sons, Inc. v. Rose & Kiernan, Inc.,7 NY3d 152, 851 NE2d I149, 818 NYS2d 798 [2006]). Accordingly, the Broker’s motion to dismiss is granted.”

Decision 4 – Appellate Court, Third Department

A run down motel in Schoharie County had a fire, (possibly arson), that occurred AFTER the policy was cancelled by the Premium Finance Company  for non-payment of the premium in accordance with NY Banking Laws. The Insured and Insurer, Seneca, were sent Notices. The Insured claims that after the loss, Seneca reinstated the policy to retroactively cover the loss. [1] Seneca denies this. No one asserted that the policy was reinstated before the loss. 

BOTH…Seneca and the Insured, in the same action, sued the Broker for various claims. Outrageously Seneca, separated from the Broker by RTS, its agent, claimed that the Broker had a Duty to affirmatively tell Seneca…DIRECTLY…of the fire before the reinstatement request.

I was not the original attorney for the Broker and they did not move for dismissal. 2 years into the case I was substituted in and I moved for dismissal. Seneca also moved against the Insured asserting that the Smoke Detectors Protective Safeguards Endorsement were violated and thus there would not have been coverage anyway.

The Lower Court judge denied both motions saying that discovery, (documents and depositions), were needed before a decision could be made. We both appealed.

On 10/29/26 the Appellate Court reversed the Lower Court’s decision granting dismissal for Seneca and my client as to ALL CLAIMS against it by Seneca and the Insured.

Critical for us is that the court REJECTED that a Broker, NOT IN PRIVITY, with the Insurer owes it ANY DUTY, let alone a duty as to claim notice which is a contractual obligation between the Insured and the Insurer.

Also, in another win on the negation of typical claims and upholding doctrines we use all the time, the court said that since the Insured violated the Protective Safeguard Endorsement and would never have had coverage under the policy anyway….even if the Broker did something wrong, the element of CAUSATION was negated and with it any claims against the Broker.        

CONCLUSION

There is an old proverb called “For the Want of a Nail”. It goes like this:

For want of a nail the shoe was lost;
For want of a shoe the horse was lost;
And for want of a horse, the rider was lost,
For want of the rider the message was lost,
For want of the message the battle was lost,
For want of the battle the war was lost,
All for want of a horse-shoe nail

It is meant to underscore both unforeseen circumstances and, for our purposes, that seemingly little things may have major significant effects down the road.

NY is the best state for Insurance Agents and Brokers defending any kind of E&O claim because for the last few decades we and the BIG I, thought E&O Seminars, Best Practices and aggressive defense of E&O casers make sure that brokers stay “Order Takers” and not Fiduciaries like in other states. That often allows Pre-Answer dismissal motions which are rare in other states.

So… no issue in NY, no case, regardless of the amount of money at issue, is too small or insignificant to go all in. Hence the NAIL analogy because ANY bad decision….is a bad precedent and could have unforeseen effect down the line. And we will not let that stand. 

But we are only half the question. So help yourself and your industry with good E&O practices. And, as always, when in doubt….contact the BIG I or me directly. We are here to help.


Submitted by:

Howard S. Kronberg, Esq.
Kaufman Dolowich, LLP

[1]  As a matter of Statute, NY Insurance law does not allow retroactive coverage of a loss that already occurred, with or without a No Known Loss Letter…..it is against the definition of DOING AN INSURANCE BUSINESS in NY as the loss is no longer a “fortuity” as per NYIL

Topics