Personal Service, More Choices: The Claims Experience at Preferred Mutual

Brought to you by our partners at Preferred Mutual Insurance Company
When you recommend an insurance carrier, the claims experience deserves a place in the conversation. Your clients want to know who will help them after a loss, how they will navigate the process, and what they can expect along the way.
At Preferred Mutual Insurance Company, we’ve continued to invest in the people, tools, and services that help answer those questions. Our focus is straightforward: give policyholders personal support and options that work for them, while helping our independent agency partners feel confident in the company they recommend.
More Preferred people in the field
Personal service starts with the people handling a claim. We continue to expand our field auto adjusting team so that the majority of our auto claims are inspected by Preferred Mutual employees. We’ve also built out our property field adjusting team to bring that same focus to property losses.
These investments help us provide a more personal experience and support quicker turnaround times. For policyholders navigating an unfamiliar situation, working directly with a member of the Preferred team brings a human connection to the process.
A claims process that gives clients choices
Every policyholder has different preferences. Some welcome the convenience of digital tools, while others feel more comfortable with familiar methods.
We’ve added texting as an option for policyholders to connect with their claims representatives. Electronic funds transfer allows claim payments to be deposited directly into their accounts, while physical checks remain available for those who prefer them.
That flexibility extends to documenting a loss. For contents claims, policyholders can upload documents through a portal or use an app to scan a room and help identify its contents for review. Those who prefer a paper form can still use one. The goal is to make the process easier to navigate in a way that fits the individual.
Practical help after water damage
After a water loss, finding a mitigation provider and coordinating services can add to an already stressful situation.
Preferred Mutual’s water mitigation program helps simplify those next steps. For policyholders who choose to use the program, we send the referral and pay the vendor directly. The vendor contacts the policyholder to schedule the appointment.
This gives customers a clear path forward, reducing the need to call around for a provider and manage direct billing for mitigation services.
Convenient inspections that help claims move forward
Virtual inspection options offer another way to make the claims process more convenient.
For property claims suited to this approach, we can send a link that allows policyholders to scan damaged areas of their home and submit that information for our team to review and prepare an estimate.
Our auto virtual inspection program similarly allows policyholders to scan their vehicle and send images to a Preferred field staff member for estimating.
These options help our claims professionals receive the information they need sooner and can support faster resolution.
What policyholders tell us
In Preferred Mutual’s closed-claim survey results conducted between August 2025 and August 2026, approximately 90% of respondents to each question said:
- Their claims representative contacted them promptly.
- The claim process was explained clearly.
- They felt their claim was settled fairly.
Those responses speak to three essentials of the claims experience:
Responsiveness, clear communication, and fair treatment.
For independent agents, these are meaningful points to discuss when helping clients choose a carrier. At Preferred Mutual, our continued investment in personal service and practical technology supports a shared goal: helping customers move forward after a loss with confidence.

Learn more about Preferred Mutual
Topics









