Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content

Premium Finance

​​​​Superior Payment Plan, LLC

Dedicated to Service
Superior Payment Plan specializes in financing commercial and personal insurance premiums for the excess and surplus insurance lines industry.

Our #1 priority is our customers. You'll notice it the first time you call and a live person answers the phone! Our staff is highly experienced (average 10+ years) and focused on helping you.​

Exclusive Member Program
As a New York-based operation, we're excited to partner with Big I NY and its members. We put together an exclusive member program with a highly competitive interest rate structure. We want to work with you and will do what it takes to make that happen. We have underwriting flexibility and can customize a program to fit your needs.

Service Standards
Superior finances insurance policies written with insurance companies with an A.M. Best Rating of A- or better and will gladly finance premiums as low as $500.

Endorsements of at least $500 in premium and at least 3 installments remaining can be added to current financing. Plus, finance agreements can be quoted from our website!​

Chosen Partner

Superior has a stellar reputation, mostly due to their unparalleled customer service! We jumped at the opportunity to partner with them because we knew they’d be great people to work with – for us and for our members. 

- Lisa Lounsbury, Big I NY President​

Producer Questionnaire​​ ​REFERENCE SHEET

Contact Superior 866.856.1112



Helen Nigro

Marketing Representative

Mobile: 716-515-5434
Office: 716-206-8288 Ext. 413

Here's what members are saying...


"Superior Payment Plan’s service from start to finish has been exemplary. Professional, knowledgeable, yet friendly -- a level that far exceeds all other Finance companies. We have recommended their services to many of our associates in the past and would not hesitate to do so going forward."

- Isabella R. Autorino, BNC Insurance Agency, Inc., Rye Brook, NY

"Vanner Insurance has experienced fantastic growth with Superior Payment Plan due to “Best in the Industry” service, communication and ease of doing business. Our expectations are always exceeded when dealing with Superior’s staff which results in very satisfied brokers and clients. We would recommend Superior Payment Plan to any Agency looking for the best in premium financing services."

- Dennis Donner, Vanner Insurance Agency, Amherst, NY 

​“I have worked with Superior Payment Plan for a number of years. The Staff are top notch professionals that offer prompt and efficient service to meet my customer needs. Their willingness to compromise far exceeds the competition in the industry.”


- Michelle Moore, Perry & Carroll, Inc., Elmira, NY

"Everyone on staff is extremely knowledgeable and accessible and will go the extra mile to assist any need that we may have. In the interest of our customers, they have tailored a very competitive rate structure. The Superior website is very user friendly and makes quoting a breeze. Our ability to log on and view customer activity is very helpful to both our agency and our customers. We would highly recommend Superior as your main option for financing."


- Vicki Del Brocco, Ten Eyck Insuring Agency Inc., Albany, NY


​"It is our responsibility as Insurance Professionals to do diligence in every aspect for our clients; right down to payment options. When needed my #1 Finance Company is Superior Payment Plan. Everyone from the support staff to management is always available to work with me to offer the most affordable terms for my clients."


- Carolyn Zaccour, Marshall & Sterling Insurance, Rochester, NY


"We could not be happier with Superior Payment Plan. Their staff is professional, knowledgeable and always willing to go above and beyond to ensure the broker and customer is satisfied. We are so pleased to have been introduced to such a “superior” finance company; always our top choice!"


- Kate Maloney Celi, Maloney & Maloney, Inc., Hampton Bays, NY​